Ignorance is bliss vs Knowledge is power.

I was having this rather interesting conversation with a friend yesterday in the midst of which I said “Not being aware of the options that you have lets you achieve happiness in your scope of life” and he goes “Yappa, now that’s gonna be in your blog tomorrow” .
Well, here it is :)

We were talking of arranged marriages.

He: Girls nowadays know exactly what they want, its not like they just accept what their parents decide is right.

Me: Obviously, they have just as much right to checking out all the options just like you would.

He: I know, it is pretty cool that they do. They want more than just a job and a family background, they want the personal details too. The girls of this generation have changed, I mean if I were to look for a girl the way my mom would do if she had her way, then I would just have to take sanyas.

Me: :)) That hard is it?

He: Everyone is educated, they know what they want. They tell me that they want to study further, I will have to go find a better job to be able to support them.

Me: :) Well, that’s the other part to it . If girls were married off before they really really figure out what they want from life, they will tend to grow into whatever they have. But if it is someone who has known independence and has learnt to think on her feet and fend for herself , she will probably have a harder time accepting a new person into her life whole-heartedly.

He: But that’s the whole point, she will be independent, she will be her own person, she will have a mind of her own. She will know how the world works and can look after herself.

Me: And because she does that, she wont be able to conform to the traditional Indian custom of being the docile wife who is expected to be one step lesser than her husband in all aspects, she is expected to be in his shadow. People may never publicly accept it and there may be quite a few guys who will treat a wife as an equal but the amount of people who can treat his wife as a superior being is almost nil. Most guys would probably want his wife to look upto him. How many girls who know that they are just as capable as him will want to ‘bow’ or ‘bend’ to his will willingly. If she does, it will be because she has to compromise, coz she doesn’t want any issue.

He: Yeah, that is sort of hard to ask a girl to act like she isn’t an equal, and of course guys would prefer to have the upper hand. And I guess girls would want a guy to look upto too. I mean they too have this culture ingrained in them like us.

Me: True. I guess it’s the way we are brought up.

(I don’t remember the conversation that went here)

Me: If someone were brought up in an atmosphere where she sees day in and day out that men resort to domestic violence at their whim and fancy, if she finds herself with a husband who thinks beating her is a norm, she probably would be able to devise a way to take it and still have a ‘normal’ relationship with him. But just imagine how appalling that idea would be to a girl who has always thought stuff like that was from during black and white movies. She would walk right out on that marriage if she couldn’t find a way to fix it.

He: :))

Me: She has her options open, she knows that this is not normal and that she has a right to expect a decent life. And she may chose to walk out but her marriage will be considered a failure though she is happier. Whereas the other woman would have made her peace and lived on finding happiness in the way she knows best. Having a limited vision lets you achieve the max in that scope. You believe you are happy and satisfied. That’s all that matters. Knowing too much doesn’t give you enough happiness if you don’t get what you consider ‘good’ stuff.

He: Too much knowledge is a bad thing, you should just have enough.

Me: Yeah, and how will we define that :-P

And then it trailed off. Well, this is but one minor aspect of the title but makes sense na.

17 comments:

Swappy March 7, 2008 at 9:44 PM  

Wow....Myths....thats a great conversation....convey the same to ur frnd too :)

But I still believe in the later part of this "Ignorance is bliss vs Knowledge is power."

Things got to change a lot, bcos, adjusting always with a person, will someday lead to the demise of once self, instead shouldn't it be mutual understanding.

Anyways, at this point, no Gyan here....so, "Ignorance is bliss" :)

Huck March 7, 2008 at 10:20 PM  
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous March 8, 2008 at 4:40 PM  

and where did my comment go.. grrr.. grrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

Anonymous March 9, 2008 at 12:36 AM  

Nice article!

The problem arises when there is a cross between the two.
Someone knowledgeable enough to know what he wants from his life and then going against it by pretending that that option/choice wasn't there at all (read ignorance).

Anonymous March 11, 2008 at 10:24 AM  

Swap,
It has to be mutual understanding.Easier said than done.The more time you spend with a person, the more you adapt to that person and in that process you definitely change.. whether it is part of the essence of you or some peripheral thing is another issue.anyway that is another huge topic on its own.
and hello, u started with the latter and finally said the former, make up ur mind !

The person who deleted the comment,
You do realise comments posted here are mailed to me, so I read what you said. since you dont want it here, I wont elaborate or reply to it, but let me say it made me smile.

anony,
aitha?


anony,
Thanks, heavily loaded statement :)
ot gonna poke my nose into that, antha heloke agatha ;)
No one will pretend unless they are forced to agree with it , whole-heartedly or otherwise.There's a reason for everything , esp. if you are giving up wat u want.

Anonymous March 11, 2008 at 3:23 PM  

So are you giving up what you want ?

Anonymous March 12, 2008 at 8:26 AM  

well,I have ALWAYS wanted to be able to eat icecreams and chocoloates daily. And I had to give it up :(
or I'd have to join Weight Watchers Anonymous ;)

Anonymous March 12, 2008 at 10:12 AM  

I believe in knowledge is power.

If I am forced to agree with something then its wrong there itself because it puts a question mark on my knowledge.
It is another thing all together that you accept other's point of view and then do something opposite to what you were supposed to do in the first place. No question of force involved here as evident from ice cream example. You accept the fact that it's bad for health and so you give it up.

Anonymous March 12, 2008 at 10:49 AM  

Welcome to the battlefield : mythsramblings.blogspot :)

Huck March 13, 2008 at 11:53 PM  

Eat ice-cream every day and join weight watchers (or) eat it now and then and skip weight watchers?
lesser of the two evils? so you did exercise 'knowledge is power' here and though you didn't get to do what you wanted, importantly you are still happy. aren't you?

If 'ignorance was bliss', then you might have been eating your way to,... ahem a very healthy lifestyle ;)

If 'ignorance is bliss' can seemingly lead you astray on such trivial decisions as it does on ice creams, imagine the havoc that it can cause on bigger decisions! The funny part is you won't even realize that until it's too late, and you might well find yourself in the middle of a holocaust, one otherwise fine day!

I do agree that knowledge is power can give you the realization that the best things didn't happen to you, but then hey! atleast you do know what is the best thing that could happen to you and maybe there is a second chance to get it on the way somewhere...! The way to happiness is to first understand what makes you happy and for that you need information,options,data none of which the ignorance is bliss mantra can hand over. Sure you might try and lose, but then there is happiness in trying.

With ignorance, neither will you ever know what works for you nor will you take any steps to attain it. You will just change because you have to and not because you want to... and then believe(rather dis-illusion yourself) that what you are experiencing is what happiness is all about.... :)

P.S: Sorry for the blog sized comment. I do get carried away some times...

Anonymous March 14, 2008 at 6:32 PM  

Yappa so many people visit your blog..wow... you must be a celebrity alva.. by the way what's the topic of discussion ?

Anonymous March 23, 2008 at 9:13 PM  

maadthini

renith March 26, 2008 at 10:03 AM  

Congratulations ;)

Anonymous April 1, 2008 at 12:44 PM  

psst you still there?

myths April 11, 2008 at 10:19 AM  

nope, i am in hiding

Shriram April 11, 2008 at 10:00 PM  

Is blog mein itne sannatta kyun hai bhayi (Yenu saddhe illa, kannada tutions ah?)

Anonymous April 13, 2008 at 11:13 PM  

super dialog ma ! :)))

Post a Comment